True crime has captivated audiences worldwide, but for many, the consequences of this fascination are deeply troubling.
True crime has surged in popularity, captivating millions with its mix of suspense and real-life intrigue. While audiences are drawn to these stories, many report increased anxiety, paranoia, and fear as a result. What seems like harmless entertainment can have lasting psychological effects on viewers.
According to a recent study by Vivint, nearly 50% of Americansspend an average of 3.8 hours per week consuming true crime content. Podcasts, documentaries, and TV shows have become an integral part of our entertainment landscape.
Of those 50% of viewers, 34% reported being more fearful of their surroundings, and 30% felt more anxious in their day to day lives.
While true crime series can impact viewers, the toll on the victims’ families is often far more profound.
One of the most notable examples is Netflix’s DAHMER – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story, which quickly became one of the platform’s most popular series’ to date.
While millions found the show captivating, the victims’ families did not share the same positive sentiment. In fact, many were forced to revisit their trauma through the depiction of their loved ones’ murders, feeling as though their pain had been turned into a form of entertainment.
A TMZ interview with Shirley Hughes, the mother of one of Jeffrey Dahmer’s victims Tony Hughes, called the role of Dahmer played by actor Evan Peters “disrespectful” and that he shouldn’t have taken the role in the first place.
“It’s a shame that people can take our tragedy and make money,” said Hughes. “The victims never saw a cent. We go through these emotions every day.”
The lack of consideration for the families in these productions is glaring. Documentary makers and producers are required to follow just two rules: portray the story accurately and respect the victims’ privacy. However, there is no obligation to contact the families or seek their permission, leaving many blindsided when their trauma is repackaged for mass consumption.
It’s important to consider the impact on our mental health and that of those who lived through these horrors.
While indulging in these stories may feel like harmless entertainment, we must remember that for the victims’ families, these are not stories—they’re real tragedies.
To support victims of violent crimes, visit the The National Center for Victims of Crime to learn how you can make a difference to those affected.
